188 Southern Historical Society Papers.
still covered all ingress to Chattanooga. What was left of the 20,000 fighting men in his corps were with him and remnants of other divisions formed on his right. The position was a strong one, and the enemy in vain attempted to carry it. Their efforts were much feebler than in the morning, though there was still danger in them.
From this time Thomas, glorious Thomas, baffled them at every point. Charge after charge he rolled off with his troops, reinspired by Granger's timely brigades. As the efforts of the enemy grew feebler, he threw forward several brigades and drove him back al- most beyond his old position, regaining one of the most important hospitals.
I firmly believe that the sudden giving way of the right division insured the salvation of the army. The right had been denuded of troops to re-enforce the left. The brave divisions that remained endeavored to close up the gaps on the double-quick. But many r as I have already said, were shot down on the march. Cut up piece- meal by that artful massing of the rebels on their own left, they must either have been surrounded or have given way as they did precip- itately.
There is every reason to believe that the sudden disappearance of these two divisions threw the enemy into equal disorder. Some of his attacking brigades were opposed and driven away in confusion; others advanced slowly through the forest, expending their ammu- nition on the vacant air. At sunset on Sunday, Bragg' s lines must have been as curiously disposed as our own.
[From the New Orleans, La., Picayune, February 1, 1903.]
LEST WE FORGET BEN BUTLER.
The Scathing Denunciation of His Course in War and Peace, Delivered in Congress by John Young Brown.
By Captain JAMES DINKINS.
Those who have respect for the maxim, de mortuis nil nisi bonum y will have very little to say for Ben Butler.
