Page:The battle of the books - Guthkelch - 1908.djvu/292

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
218
APPENDIX

no reason to be afraid of their resentments. It does not appear to me, that Mr B. has any commission to threaten thus in their name: and if he has not, his making use of their authority is a sort of libel upon them, which would represent a great body of learned men as the partakers and patrons of the faults of his book. I have a true honour and great esteem for that noble and flourishing society which is supposed to be meant here; and I should think I did them a great injury to suspect they will interpose in Phalaris's behalf. For when a cause cannot be defended, the numbers ot those that engage in't make it only the more scandalous.

But since Mr B. has been so free as to threaten a reply, even before he sees what I say in my defence; though I will not prescribe to so great a genius any method of his answer, yet I think I may make bold to tell him what I shall look upon to be no answer.

1. If he pretends that he did not maintain that his Phalaris is genuine; but only that my arguments do not prove him to be otherwise, I shall look upon this as a shuffle, and no answer at all. For if he suspects whether he's genuine, and yet allows none of my