Page:Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States (1st ed, 1833, vol I).djvu/173

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
CH. XVI.]
GENERAL REVIEW.
133

inconsistent with their comfort and prosperity. There is, therefore, this necessarj limitation implied, that they carry with them all the laws applicable to their situation, and not repugnant to the local and political circumstances, in which they are placed.

§ 149. Even as thus stated, the proposition is full of vagueness and perplexity; for it must still remain a question of intrinsic difficulty to say, what laws are, or are not applicable to their situation; and whether they are bound by the present state of things, or are at liberty to apply them in future by adoption, as the growth or interests of the colony may dictate.[1] The English rules of inheritance, and of protection from personal injuries, the rights secured by Magna Charta, and the remedial course in the administration of justice, are examples as clear perhaps as any, which can be stated, as presumptively adopted, or applicable. And yet in the infancy of a colony some of these very rights, and privileges, and remedies, and rules, may be in fact inapplicable, or inconvenient, and impolitic.[2] It is not perhaps easy to settle, what parts of the English laws are, or are not in force in any such colony, until either by usage, or judicial determination, they have been recognized as of absolute force.

§ 150. In respect to conquered and ceded countries, which have already laws of their own, a different rule prevails. In such cases the crown has a rieht to abrogate the former laws, and institute new ones. But until such new laws are promulgated, the old laws and customs of the country remain in full force, unless so
  1. 1 Bl. Comm. 107; 2 Merivale R. 143, 159.
  2. 1 Bl. Comm. 107; 1 Tucker's Black, note E. 378, 384 et seq.; 4 Burr. R. 2500; 2 Merivale R. 143, 157, 158; 2 Wilson's Law Lect. 49 to 54.