Page:Popular Science Monthly Volume 76.djvu/235

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
SECOND LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
231

Simple Knowledge Assumed

A great deal of simple every-day knowledge is always taken for granted in a treatise on thermodynamics. It is stated above that the important things in connection with the generation of steam in a boiler by the burning of coal are (a) the temperature of the feed water, (b) the temperature and pressure of the steam which is produced, (c) the character of the coal, (d) the temperature and composition of the air, and (e) the temperature and composition of the flue gases. In a certain sense this is true, but of course the fundamentally important thing is the knowledge that coal will burn and convert water into steam. Such fundamental knowledge is always taken for granted in the study of thermodynamics. The nature of fire is not an object of study in thermodynamics, but every one knows what fire is in a simple practical way; every one knows that an object becomes hot when it is placed upon a hot stove; and every one knows that steam will squirt out of a hole in a steam boiler under pressure. In the experience of the writer only one case has ever come to notice in which this kind of fundamental knowledge seemed to be lacking. A student was asked to define what is meant by the heat of combustion of coal, and he gave it correctly up to a certain point by saying that it was the number of thermal units generated by one pound of coal; it was, however, impossible to lead the young man by indirect suggestion to add the important qualifying phrase "when the coal is burned," and upon being asked explicitly how one gets heat out of coal, the young man actually replied, with some embarrassment, "Why, Professor, I don't know." Of course, he did know, but apparently he could only think that the study of thermodynamics must refer to unfamiliar and elegant things. No, thermodynamics refers to the things of the kitchen and to the things of the furnace, although the science of thermodynamics is so organized that it talks only of the things that go into and of the things which come out of those mysterious places where maids and furnace-men rule.

Limitations of Mechanics

The science of mechanics applies to the more or less ideal phenomena which are associated with the motion of rigid bodies either singly or in connected machines; with the regular motion of distortion of elastic bodies like the bending of a bow or the oscillation of a string; and with ideally simple motion of flow of liquids and gases like the smooth flow of water from an orifice in a tank. In every actual case of motion, however, we always encounter turbulence more or less marked, and the science of mechanics, which is the science of describing the phenomena of motion, fails utterly if we attempt to consider the