wiappeE, and folfl it ,right o^eI! th.e gaateboatdi wMch: forms �the box." ■ -f ,-;■'. -^i^; '.il' ' ' ^ i-; i. - '■ >■ ' '" �In view of sucb testimony it « not gujiprising that the complainants did.noi,appe^r.,atitl;ia,heaTing ta gustainthe validity of their patejat. , .Jt isiantioipatediby these eSbibits, and, being void, f or . wan,t ot novelty, tha complainants' bill must be dismisped withiflosts; .:, . > ; j'; ���il_ui'):!:: ���, 'iOiie .for thf RT^^uct. ^ fflf 4)»a|.^.^h^;ce-}^S,u^|f}«V-thS. IffC^HCf .^?« '"Valia.— [Ed; - , ■ , �.toiiuji! niM jiu -^f hbiKiu c^irv i-}f\,<.>v.[ ')'n ,w; i;n,:j!<[ .Jni'i>i'«q �., „.^(3[^i4>iE.;J(£ai;n?g4^fK'flma J^>,v<p.. Awwi«*'&>i3i©WnpIak»»nt«^^ il C'|i,a^^6s.^..^iifoAfift49^de(Eaiidffiit.) i; ; ar;8 .b\ ,i»juvr.i>'jV .v _ ,Lpwsij^,,„C.\ J[,.,tiIii,|i<cfio^4w%e)ii-wJiti» to^iiStipttlatioji'MltiW PWt jje^jj)f|iijc}i, ,^ft Jt>rftugtiii .^fti c,«eiPi t.(^: a :mtr<m^f^Ua.f^&iA ^W%^.^K^ i^S Jp;?i4 Wfi? .flraJijii litc^c^^Mj i«jp8Bs% I fcaA bayft cjarifff «lfe9/)iisi^|(^^)yj^i|itj>jpr,flifth|ftc; flf ithf ife»r ««hibita^ jffiibA o^ r as, infrjjijg^^n^^ijwerQi .fcid. l?y : ^K^i dff^tldftpt, T»ithia;itej tij^f 8 e^bj^ced . ^ thfi, ,9tipHiatw»K )ma, i& (.«PJf ) *^*r«^ siMh ■whether t^^^y a^e;"T,ijc^ejr l?irpflpzc^"ii ;ihPiep.s©bas,ibfl«JB befoises the .cpiwtif^ vfl,ri!?ins,p,^gesi and]tbfi,parti€i8( '«Ljfepi'ested a^fe joiOt,j at,preseijjE|c^isagfee4.ast9.,wfr^A9/^h^'{r»cli»j4'biiw,!?e;Qlaime^ in re-i.s8p^,,No.: 2,3r56, n%raei^„,p;pji,is;arm8hed^(M;ji9iIjad ,and. he^ted, eitlief, in , one o.p)f Fatiion^or, iWorei, jn. such • ja) pvanner that a coloi^i ^baji ;be imp^ijted tc^ the; iron ; itself hj the beat and also to theoil pryarujsl^.; If, ,the iron is first colored,/ and then merely vamigl^ejj» or if the coMingof varnisb alone is colored,^ the invention ha8,not j)c;en practiced, so farias the present case is concernedi ,. , �Qi the four exhibits, it ip, not proTed tp my satisfaction that Nos. 1 and 2 were sold by the defendant at times or in a ��� �
