must be proportional to the quantities respectively. If is an element of the curve; the point upon the auxiliary sphere, which represents the direction of this element; the point giving the direction of the normal as above; and the coordinates of the points referred to the centre of the auxiliary sphere, then we have
Therefore we see that the above differentials will be equal to And since are proportional to the quantities the character of the shortest line is such that
To every point of a curved line upon a curved surface there correspond two points on the sphere, according to our point of view; namely, the point which represents the direction of the linear element, and the point which represents the direction of the normal to the surface. The two are evidently apart. In our former investigation (Art. 9), where [we] supposed the curved line to lie in a plane, we had two other points upon the sphere; namely, which represents the direction of the normal to the plane, and which represents the direction of the normal to the element of the curve in the plane. In this case, therefore, was a fixed point and were always in a great circle whose pole was In generalizing these considerations, we shall retain the notation but we must define the meaning of these symbols from a more general point of view. When the curve is described, the points also describe curved lines upon the auxiliary sphere, which, generally speaking, are no longer great circles. Parallel to the element of the second line,