Page:Philosophy and Fun of Algebra.djvu/25

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been validated.

SIMULTANEOUS PROBLEMS


If the result of doing so is to bring out some such ridiculous answer as "2 and 3 make 7," we then know that x cannot be 1. We now add to our column of data, "x cannot be 1."

But if we come to a truism, such as "2 and 3 make 5," we add to our column of data, "x may be 1." Some people add to their column of data, "x is 1," but that again is not Algebra.

Next we try the experiment of supposing x to be equal to zero (0), and go over the ground again.

Then we go over the same ground, trying y as 1 and as 0.

And then we try the same with z.

Some people think that it is waste of time to go over all this ground so carefully, when all you get by it is either nonsense, such as "2 and 3 are 7"; or truisms, such as "2 and 3 are 5." But it is not waste of time. For, even if we never arrive at finding out the value of x, or y, or z, every conscientious attempt such as I have described adds to our knowledge of the structure of Algebra, and assists us in solving other problems.

21