not appeal with force and success to the general reader. Its appeal, we think, would be to the small class of cultured readers, and therefore its publication would not be attended with commercial success. Therefore in your interest, as well as our own, we feel that we must give an unfavorable decision upon the question of publication. Naturally we regret to be forced to that conclusion, for the work is one which would be creditable to any publisher's list. We return the manuscript by express, with our appreciation of your courtesy in giving us the opportunity of considering it, and are, etc."
And so it was with The Gayvery Company, and
with Leeds, McKibble & Todd, and with Stuyvesant
& Brothers. Unanimously they united to
praise and to return the manuscript. And Kennaston
began reluctantly to suspect that, for all
their polite phrases about literary excellence, his
romance must, somehow, be not quite in consonance
with the standards of that person who is,
after all, the final arbiter of literature, and to
whom these publishers very properly deferred, as
"the general reader." And Kennaston wondered
if it would not be well for him, also, to study the
