Atheism of the Epicureans, it will be seen that he is equally temperate, and equally consistent with himself, in avoiding the exaggerated zeal of those Stoics who, in their eager desire to do something for the honour of Providence, had subjected the minutest and commonest actions of life to the jealous watching of an arbitrary omniscience, so that, as Wyttenbach puts it, "that most gracious name of Providence was exposed to ridicule and contempt, being alternately regarded as a fortune-telling old crone, and as a dreadful spectre to alarm and terrify mankind."
Let us see in what way Plutarch establishes the providential benevolence of God without detracting from his majesty.
A company of philosophic students, Plutarch himself; Patrocleas, his son-in-law;[1] Timon, his brother; and Olympichos, a friend;[2] are found, at the opening of the dialogue, regarding each other in silence beneath a Portico of the Delphic Temple, in wonder at the discourtesy of an Epicurean who has suddenly disappeared from the party, after expounding the doctrines of his school in the manner, doubtless, of Velleius in the "De Natura Deorum," though with a more limited scope as expressed by the famous line of Ennius already quoted. According to Plutarch, he had "gathered together, from various sources, an undigested mass of confused observations, and had then scattered them in one contemptuous stream of spleen and anger upon Providence." The company, deprived of their legitimate
