Schrimpscher v. Stockton

by Henry Billings Brown

United States Supreme Court

183 U.S. 290

Schrimpscher  v.  Stockton

 Argued: November 22, 1901. --- Decided: January 6, 1902

This was an action of ejectment brought in the court of common pleas of Wyandotte county, Kansas, by John Schrimpscher and about forty others, heirs of one Carey Rodgers, deceased, a Wyandotte Indian, against John S. Stockton and ten others, to recover a tract of land which had been allotted to certain Wyandotte Indians under the treaty of 1855.

Answers were filed by three of the defendants, containing general denials of the allegations of the petition, and pleas both of a three-year and a fifteen-year state statute of limitations.

To these answers plaintiffs filed a reply to the effect that the ancestor of the plaintiffs, from whom they derived title by descent, was an incompetent Indian, and classed as such under the treaty between the United States and the Wyandotte tribe of Indians, concluded January 31, 1855, and, as such incompetent, was prohibited from alienating any of the lands in controversy, except only the power to lease the same for the term of two years; that defendants and those under whom they claim were bound by the same prohibition, and could have acquired nothing further than such leasehold interest in the land; that defendants occupied such lands in subordination to the rights of plaintiffs' ancestor, and that no notice had ever been brought home to plaintiffs of an adverse claim by defendants.

A jury having been waived and the case submitted to the court, judgment was rendered for the defendants. An appeal was taken to the supreme court of the state, which affirmed the judgment of the lower court. 58 Kan. 758, 51 Pac. 276. Whereupon plaintiffs sued out a writ of error from this court.

Messrs. William M. Springer, James M. Mason, and Charles H. Nearing for plaintiffs in error.

No brief was filed for defendants in error.

Mr. Justice Brown delivered the opinion of the court:

Notes