Page:A critical and exegetical commentary on Genesis (1910).djvu/316

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page needs to be proofread.

5 ff.). "Keftiu is the old Eg. name of Caphtor (Crete), Keptar a Ptolemaic doublet of it, taken over when the original meaning of Keftiu had been forgotten, and the name had been erroneously applied to Phœnicia" (Hall, Man, Nov. 1903, No. 92, p. 162 ff.). In OLz., M. questions the originality of the name in this passage: so also Je. ATLO2, 275.[1]


15-19. The Canaanites.—The peoples assigned to the Canaanitish group are (1) the Phœnicians ((Symbol missingHebrew characters)), (2) the Ḥittites ((Symbol missingHebrew characters)), and (3) a number of petty communities perhaps summed up in the phrase (Symbol missingHebrew characters) in 18b. It is surprising to find the great northern nation of the Ḥittites classed as a subdivision of the Canaanites. The writer may be supposed to have in view offshoots of that empire, which survived, as small enclaves in Palestine proper; but that explanation does not account for the marked prominence given to Ḥeth over the little Canaanite kingships. On the other hand, one hesitates to adopt Gu.'s theory that (Symbol missingHebrew characters) is here used in a wide geographical sense as embracing the main seats of the Ḥittite empire (p. 187). There is evidence, however, of a strong settlement of Ḥittites near Ḥermon (see below), and it is conceivable that these were classed as Canaanites and so inserted here.


Critically, the vv. are difficult. We. (Comp.2 15) and others remove 16-18a as a gloss: because (a) the boundaries laid down in 19 are exceeded in 17. 18a, and (b) the mention of a subsequent dispersion of Canaanites (18b) has no meaning after 16-18a. That is perhaps the most reasonable view to take; but even so 18b does not read quite naturally after 15; and what could have induced a glossator to insert four of the most northerly Phœnician cities, passing by those best known to the Hebrews? Is it


15. (Symbol missingHebrew characters)] cf. 2221 (J).—18. (Symbol missingHebrew characters)] adv. of time, as 185 2455 3021 etc. = (Symbol missingHebrew characters): see BDB, 29 f.—(Symbol missingHebrew characters)] Niph. fr. [root] (Symbol missingHebrew characters); see on 919: cf. 114. 8. 9.—(Symbol missingHebrew characters)]] can hardly, even if the clause be a gloss, denote the Phœn. colonies on the Mediterranean (Brown, EB, ii. 1698 f.).—19. (Symbol missingHebrew characters)] 'as one comes' (see G-K. § 144 h) might be taken as 'in the direction of' (so Di. Dri. al.); but there does not appear to be any clear case in which the expression differs from (Symbol missingHebrew characters) = 'as far as' (cf. 1030 1310 2518 [all J], 1 Sa. 157 with Ju. 64 1133, 1 Sa. 1752, 2 Sa. 525, 1 Ki. 1846).—(Symbol missingHebrew characters)] G (Symbol missingGreek characters).

  1. V.13f. present so many peculiar features—the regular use of the pl., the great preponderance of quadriliteral names, all vocalised alike—that we can hardly help suspecting that they are a secondary addition to the Table, written from specially intimate acquaintance with the (later?) Egyptian geography.