Page:O. F. Owen's Organon of Aristotle Vol. 1 (1853).djvu/26

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been validated.
8
ARISTOTLE'S ORGANON.
[CHAP. V.

definition of man will be predicated of "some certain man," for "a certain man" is both "man" and "animal;" wherefore both the name and the definition will be predicated of a subject. 4. The contrary happens in the case of many inhesions. But of things which are in a subject, for the most part, neither the name nor the definition is predicated of the subject, yet with some, there is nothing to prevent the name from being sometimes predicated of the subject, though the definition cannot be so; as "whiteness" being in a body, as in a subject, is predicated of the subject, (for the body is termed "white,") but the definition of "whiteness" can never be predicated of body. All other things, however, are either predicated of primary substances, as of subjects, or are inherent in them as in subjects;[1] this, indeed, is evident, from several obvious instances, thus "animal" is predicated of "man," and therefore is also predicated of some "certain man," for if it were predicated of no "man" particularly, neither could it be of "man" universally. 5. The universal involves the particular. Again, "colour" is in "body," therefore also is it in "some certain body," for if it were not in "some one" of bodies singularly, it could not be in "body" universally; so that all other things are either predicated of primary substances as of subjects, or are inherent in them as in subjects; if therefore the primal substances do not exist, it is impossible that any one of the rest should exist.

6. Species more a substance than genus. But of secondary substances, species is more substance than genus;[2] for it is nearer to the primary substance, and if any one explain what the primary substance is, he will explain it more clearly and appropriately by giving the species, rather than the genus; as a person defining "a certain man" would do so more clearly, by giving "man" than "animal," for the former is more the peculiarity of "a certain man," but the latter is more common. In like manner, whoever explains what "a certain tree" is, will define it in a more known and appropriate manner, by introducing "tree" than "plant." 7. Primary substances become subjects to all predicates; Besides the primary substances, because of their subjection to all other things, and these last being
  1. Plato, in the Philebus, observes, that a philosopher ought not to descend, below wholes, and common natures.
  2. Vide supra, note; also Metaph. lib. iv. and vi.