Page:O. F. Owen's Organon of Aristotle Vol. 2 (1853).djvu/282

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
630
THE INTRODUCTION OF PROPHYRY.
[CHAP. XII. XIV,

(for rational and mortal are joined for the subsistence of man,) but species is not joined with species, so as to produce some other species; for indeed a certain horse is joined with a certain ass, for the production of a mule, but horse simply joined with ass will not produce a mule.

Chap. XIII.Of Community and Difference of Property and Difference.[1]

1. Difference and property equally participated: their relative peculiarities.Difference also and property have it in common to be equally shared by their participants, for rational are equally rational, and risible (equally) risible (animals). Also it is common to both to be always present, and to every one, for though a biped should be mutilated, yet (the term biped) is always predicated with reference to what is naturally adapted, since also risible has the "always" from natural adaptation, but not from always laughing. Now, it is the property of difference, that it is frequently predicated of many species, as rational of divinity and man, but property (is predicated) of one species, of which it is the property. Difference moreover follows those things of which it is the difference, yet does not also reciprocate, but properties are reciprocally predicated of those of which they are the properties, in consequence of reciprocating.

Chap. XIV.Of Community and Difference of Accident and Differences.[2]

1. Difference and accident predicated "de pluribus:" dis-To difference and accident it is common to be predicated of many things, but it is common (to the former) with inseparable accidents to be pre-

  1. Whately observes, "It is often hard to distinguish certain properties from differentia, but whatever you consider as the most essential to the nature of a species, with respect to the matter you are engaged in, you must call the differentia, as rationality to man, and whatever you consider as rather an accompaniment (or result) of that difference, you must call the property, as the use of speech seems to be a result of rationality. He adds also, that the difference is not always one quality, but is frequently compounded of several together, no one of which would alone suffice." Vide also Huyshe's Log., pp. 33, 34.
  2. Cf. notes at ch. 3; Whately, ii. 5, 3; Wallis, lib. i. ch. 5 and 6; Metap. lib. v. (vi.) 2.