Michelson v. United States/Concurrence Frankfurter

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
903937Michelson v. United States — ConcurrenceFelix Frankfurter
Court Documents
Case Syllabus
Opinion of the Court
Concurring Opinion
Frankfurter
Dissenting Opinion
Rutledge

United States Supreme Court

335 U.S. 469

Michelson  v.  United States

 Argued: Oct. 14, 15, 1948. --- Decided: Dec 20, 1948


Mr. Justice FRANKFURTER, concurring.

Despite the fact that my feelings run in the general direction of the views expressed by Mr. Justice RUTLEDGE in his dissent, I join the Court's opinion. I do so because I believe it to be unprofitable, on balance, for appellate courts to formulate rigid rules for the exclusion of evidence in courts of law that outside them would not be regarded as clearly irrelevant in the determination of issues. For well-understood reasons this Court's occasional ventures in formulating such rules hardly encourage confidence in denying to the federal trial courts a power of control over the allowable scope of cross-examination possessed by trial judges in practically all State courts. After all, such uniformity of rule in the conduct of trials in the crystallization of experience even when due allowance is made for the force of imitation. To reject such an impressive body of experience would imply a more dependable wisdom in a matter of this sort than I can claim.

To leave the District Courts of the United States the discretion given to them by this decision presupposes a high standard of professional competence, good sense, fairness and courage on the part of the federal district judges. If the United States District Courts are not manned by judges of such qualities, appellate review, no matter how stringent, can do very little to make up for the lack of them.

Mr. Justice RUTLEDGE, with whom Mr. Justice MURPHY joins, dissenting.

Notes

[edit]

This work is in the public domain in the United States because it is a work of the United States federal government (see 17 U.S.C. 105).

Public domainPublic domainfalsefalse