been a great deal too cruel, and much exceeding the offence; for though most
authors think, that a contemptuous manner of treating their writings is but
slightly revenged by hurting the personal character and the honour of their
antagonists, I am very far from being of that opinion. Besides, as I am as certain
as I can be of any thing, (and I am not such a sceptic as you may perhaps
imagine,) that your inserting such remarkable alterations in the printed copy
proceeded entirely from precipitancy and passion, not from any formed intention of deceiving the society, I would not take advantage of such an incident,
to throw a slur on a man of merit, whom I esteem though I might have reason
to complain of him. When I am abused by such a fellow as Warburton, whom
I neither know nor care for, I can laugh at him. But if Dr Stewart approaches
any way towards the same style of writing, I own it vexes me ; because I conclude that some unguarded circumstances of my conduct, though contrary to my
intention had given occasion to it. As to your situation with regard to lord
Kames, I am not so good a judge. I only know, that you had so much the
better of the argument that you ought upon that account to have been more
reserved in your expressions. All raillery ought to be avoided in philosophical
argument, both because (it is) unphilosophical, and because it cannot but be
offensive, let it be ever so gentle. What then must we think with regard to so
many insinuations of irreligion. to which lord Kames's paper gave not the least
occasion ? This spirit of the inquisitor is, in you, the effect of passion, and what
a cool moment would easily correct. But when it predominates in the character, what ravages has it committed on reason, virtue, truth, sobriety, and every
thing that is valuable among mankind ! " We may at this period of his life consider Hume as having reached the age when the mind has entirely ceased to
bend to circumstances, and cannot be made to alter its habits. Speaking of him
in this advanced period of his life, an author signing himself G. N. and detailing
some anecdotes of Hume, with whom he says he was acquainted, states (in the
Scots Magazine), that " his great views of being singular, and a vanity to show
himself superior to most people, led him to advance many axioms that were dissonant to the opinions of others, and led him into sceptical doctrines, only to
show how minute and puzzling they were to other folk ; in so far, that I have
often seen him (in various companies, according as he saw some enthusiastic
person there), combat either their religious or political principles; nay, after
he had struck them dumb, take up the argument on their side, with equal good
humour, wit, and jocoseness, all to show his pre-eminency." The same person
mentions his social feelings, and the natural disposition of his temper to flow
with the current of whatever society he was in ; and that while he never gambled he had a natural liking to whist playing, and was so accomplished a player as to be the subject of a shameless proposal on the part of a needy man of rank, for bettering their mutual fortunes, which it need not be said was repelled.
But the late lamented Henry M'Kenzie, who has attempted to embody the character of the sceptic in the beautiful fiction of La Roche, has drawn, from his intimate knowledge of character, and his great acquaintance with the philosopher, a more pleasing picture. His words are, " The unfortunate nature of his opinions with regard to the theoretical principles of moral and religious truth, never influenced his regard for men who held very opposite sentiments on those subjects, which he never, like some vain shallow sceptics, introduced into social discourse; on the contrary, when at any time the conversation tended that way, he was desirous rather of avoiding any serious discussion on matters which he wished to confine to the graver and less dangerous consideration of cool philosophy. He had, it might be said, in the language which the Grecian historian applies to an illustrious Roman, two minds ; one which indulged in the meta-
