XIV MEINDERT HOBBEMA 45 1 A COMPARATIVE TABLE The number in the first column of a picture described in Smith's Catalogue, vol. vi. (1835), or Smith's Supplement (1842), corresponds in this catalogue to the number given in the second or third column respectively. Thus, if the reader desires to find Sm. Suppl. 10, he must look for 10 in the first column and then notice the corresponding number in the third column headed " Sm. Suppl.," namely, 158. Thus, Sm. Suppl. io = HdG. 158. Sm. Sm. Suppl. Sm. Sm. Sm. I 136 149 33 9 6 65 121 97 112 2 164 26l 34 54 66 1 68 98 233 3 85 252 35 275 67 86 99 130 4 49" 99 36 199 68 213 IOO 171 5 191 159 37 202 69 = Sm. 3 101 223 6 see 291 = Sm. 94 38 see 291 70 ii IO2 80 7 251*2 234 39 45 7i 9 103 137 8 see 291 = Sm. 80 40 260 72 243 104 288 9 194 = Sm. 58 4 1 272 73 1 60 I0 5 71 10 106 158 4 2 204 74 217 106 ( 3 ) ii 227 108 43 203 75 69 107 "3 12 173 = Sm. 44 44
- 44*
76 224 108 276 13 So = Sm. 45 45 176 77 237 109 169 H 44 = Sm. 46 46 245 78 114 no 140 15 209 = Sm. 26 47 215 79 1 80 in 253 16 1 66 = Sm. 57 48 see 291 80 127 112 214 17 172 = Sm. 83 49 205 81 212 "3 79 18 236 = Sm. 100 5 122 82 118 114 78 '9 270 131 5i 77 83 IO4 "5 220 20 195 93 52 28 84 68 116 10 21 196 = Sm. 85 53 89 85 165 117 IIO 22 52 = Sm. 107 54 75 86 42 118 H7 23 see 291 = Sm. 121 55 59 87 73 119 = Sm. 87 2 4 97 132 56 161 88 13 1 20 238 25 56 IOO 57 67 89 H5 121 66 26 256 119 58 "5 90 ( 2 ) 122 39 27 146 150 59 6 9 1 650 123 82 28 3 181 60 242 92 87 124 129 29 141 = Sm. 73 61 76 93 210 I2 5 109 3 C 1 ) 62 218 94 263 126 216 3i 98 63 162 95 211 127 219 32 167 64 1 20 96 283 1 "A View of a Dutch Mansion-house," successively in the Erard sale, 1832, in the collection of Prince Demidoff at San Donate, and in the collection of Arthur Sanderson, Edinburgh, is not a Hobbema. 2 "The Market-day," in the possession of T. Emmerson in 1835, and last seen in the sale of Stephen G. Holland, London, June 25, 1908, No. 125, is not by M. Hobbema. 3 "A Woody Scene with Cottages," in the Revil collection, Paris, in 1835, is a characteristic G. van Hees.
