The slow and whispered admonitions of publick opinion
to tyranny, are struggles of nature for her rights, excited
by acquisitions of knowledge; like the efforts and uneasiness of a strong man, long confined in darkness, excited by
a ray of light. Upon every appearance of these struggles,
orders and exclusive privileges cry out, that kings, aristoorats, priests and privileges ought to unite, and confine her
in stronger bonds. What is thus feared, flattered and fettered, cannot be a shadow. Had it been a shadow, it would
not have been regarded and treated like a strong man in
pursuit of his rights, by those who withhold them.
If national sovereignty may be assailed, it may be defended. Said an American general to his men, "you see those fellows yonder, if you don't kill them, they will kill you." By the same terms, the attention of national sovereignty or publick opinion, would be correctly and emphatically directed to orders and exclusive privileges. This would be incorrect, says Mr. Adams's system; orders and exclusive privileges do not kill publick opinion, they only gag her with law, and point at her breast the bayonets of a standing army, lest she should use force to free her intellects. Still this system asserts, that publick opinion will have an influence over despotism itself. Stephano gags Trinculo. lest he should speak; cuts off his fingers, lest he should write; and imprisons him for groaning; yet Trinculo retains an influence over Stephano, arising from an apprehension of his escape. But an image, sometimes worshipped and sometimes whipt, by its savage subjects, is a less miserable sovereign than Trinculo.
The effects of a sovereignty of law over discussion and opinion are multifarious; all of them are sappers of the principle of national self government. A few more will be adduced.
It begins, by making it criminal to calumniate a form of government; it proceeds, to make it criminal to calumniate those individuals invested with most power, and most subject to the crime of usurpation; and it ends by making
