moved to declare that no pretext could justify the refusal
to pay the same feudal dues as before. Duport proposed
that the motion be sent back to the Bureaux. The
Assembly came to no conclusion. In truth, the thing
proposed was impossible. The Commons, who now prevailed, could not, after sitting three months, re-impose,
even provisionally, burdens which were odious, which their
Instructions condemned, and which they all knew to be
incapable of defence. There had been time to provide:
the crisis now found them unprepared. The Court advised
the nobles that nothing could save them but a speedy
surrender. They also were informed, by Barere, that some
of his friends intended to move the abolition of fiscal and
feudal privilege. They replied that they would do it
themselves. Virieu, who afterwards disappeared in a
sortie, during the siege of Lyons, said to a friend: "There are only two means of calming an excited populace, kindness and force. We have no force; we hope to succeed
by kindness." They knew that precious time had been
lost, and they resolved that the surrender should be so
ample as to be meritorious. It was to be not the redress
of practical grievances, but the complete establishment of
the new principle, equality.
At a conference held on the evening of August 3 it was agreed that the self-sacrifice of the ancient aristocracy of France, and the institution in its place of a society absolutely democratic, should be made by the Duke d'Aiguillon, the owner of vast domains, who was about to forfeit several thousands a year. But on August 4 the first to speak was Noailles; then d'Aiguillon, followed by a deputy from Brittany. You cannot repress violence, said the Breton, unless you remove the injustice which is the cause of it. If you mean to proclaim the Rights of Man, begin with those which are most flagrantly violated. They proposed that rights abandoned to the State should be ceded unconditionally, and that rights abandoned to the people should be given up in return for compensation. They imagined that the distinction was founded on principle; but nobody ever ascertained the
