Page:Schenck v. Knight.pdf/14

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
Ark.]
Schenck v. Knight
1021

If Donna Marie has married and now has a home of her own, such evidence is not in the record now before us and we, of course, are confined to the record. If Donna Marie's present age and marital status have brought about such change in condition that would justify a change in custody, there is nothing to prevent her from presenting such evidence as may now be available but, from the record before us, it would appear that the Chancery Court of Garland County would be the proper forum in which to present such evidence.

The order of the chancery court is affirmed on the record now before us.

Affirmed.

BYRD, J., dissents.

CONLEY BYRD, Justice, dissenting. Sometime ago I employed a contractor to do some clearing for me with a bulldozer. The hire of the machine together with an operator was approximately fifty cents per minute. During the clearing operation a mother hen, of the bantam variety, attacked the bulldozer with such ferociousness that it attracted not only my attention but that of my dogs and a horse in the vicinity. I still remember how my heart leaped with joy when the operator, with a kindly smile, stopped the dozer for three or four minutes to let the hen remove her day-old brood from the path of the dozer. It was such a graphic demonstration of the unselfish devotion of motherhood to its offspring that it reminded me of the incident before King Solomon where the real mother quickly consented that her child be given to an impostor rather than have it split between the mother and the other claimant of the child. I'm sure that my brethren in the majority have all had as many graphic demonstrations as I of the response of motherhood and that in reaching their conclusions they have done as much soul searching in arriving at their conclusions. Having heard their discussions in this matter, I must admit that there is some practicality to their approach. I probably would have acquiesced in their considered judgment had the majority opinion given visitation rights to Donna Marie.