Page:Scientific Monthly, volume 14.djvu/40

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
32
THE SCIENTIFIC MONTHLY

ably better on this kind of test than on tests of the Binet type, perhaps because it is more subject to the influence of schooling.


Kent-Rosanoff Association Test

K presented no symptoms whatever of psychopathological tendencies, but the Kent-Rosanoff test was given in order to compare his responses with those found by the authors for typical dull subjects. The results showed 14 per cent. of "individual" and 4 per cent. of "doubtful" reactions. Kent and Rosanoff found 6.8 per cent. of individual responses for normal adults, 14.3 per cent. for normal ten-year olds, and 26.8 per cent. for insane adults. Eastman and Rosanoff found 13.2 per cent. for delinquents (presumably averaging much be low normal in intelligence). Accordingly, as far as individual responses are concerned. K's performance resembles that of a dull youth or normal child.

The median frequency of the responses was 22, which is considerably lower than for normal adults. In this case, the low score indicates dull ness rather than mental eccentricity. There were no predicate reactions.

There was only one instance of failure to respond, and seven instances of perseverance. These figures are not greatly different from those found for normal adults.

Average reaction time was 3.1 seconds. ± 1.54. The average for college students is usually between 1.5 and 2.25; for children or men tally inferior adults, about 3. Four responses required more than 10 seconds. K s slow reaction time, as well as the quality of his responses, indicates mental inferiority.

Educational Tests

Handwriting. Smooth and legible, entirely lacking in infantile qualities. Grades 14 on Thorndike scale.

Kansas silent reading. Slightly better than eighth grade ability.

Buckingham spelling test. Lists 1 and 2. Better than ninth grade ability.

Courtis arithmetic. The results are shown in the following table:

Process  Attempts   Right  Notes
Addition 16 11 Far above eighth grade.
Subtraction 14 11 Above eighth grade.
Multiplication 11  7 Slightly below eighth grade.
Division  7  4 Between fifth and sixth grade.
Speed of Reasoning    5  2 About fifth grade.


The striking thing in the above table is the rapid deterioration in quality of performance in the successive parts of the test from addition to reasoning. That is, the higher the mental processes involved in a test, the more clearly it brings out K's subnormality. In speed and accuracy of adding he compares favorably with the average high school pupil, while in arithmetical reasoning he is little above fifth-grade ability. Three errors, all as absurd as the following, were made in indicating operations necessary to solve problems: