1-8 Southern Historical Society Papers.
8th. Failure to occupy Gulp's Hill on ist, without opposition, which would have driven the enemy from Cemetery Hill.
9th. A great error in attacking the third day on a line six miles long, and without simultaneous effort, instead of concentrating two corps against the enemy's left, as General Lee intended, and moving forward to the attack successive divisions, until the adversary was overwhelmed, his line broken, and his left turned. The even bal- ance of the day as it was shows that this strategy would have suc- ceeded.
The battle of Gettysburg was fought on 3rd in reality by three divisions Pickett's, Heth's, under Pettigrew, Pender's, under Trim- ble all concentrated on the enemy's left centre. Longstreet's two right divisions were not put in earnestly. Two divisions of Hill were in position on Seminary Ridge, and Swell's Corps on left, held in threatening attitude.
It was evident that in General Lee's position, distant from his supplies and from all reinforcements, and inferior in numbers, that these disadvantages could only be neutralized by repeated and hard blows, dealt so rapidly that the enemy would not have time to mature any plan or to put himself in a secure position. General Lee fully realized this, and as soon as he was aware that the enemy were at Gettysburg, was earnest in a desire to push our success the first day, and to attack by daylight on 2nd. This was prevented by the indecision of his corps commanders.
Both armies were exhausted by the great efforts and sacrifices that had been made, and seemed willing to end the campaign without further struggle.
But there is no question that, as General Lee hoped and believed, a successful battle in Pennsylvania would have secured Southern independence.
