attended a dinner of the Socialist Press Club, at which the question of dishonest newspapers was debated, and one of the speakers was Mr. Fabian Franklin, then editor of the "Evening Post," an amiable old gentleman who quite naïvely referred to the Associated Press as he would have referred to the Holy Trinity. He told of some radical friend of his who had pointed out that the Associated Press had circulated the news of a defeat of the Initiative and Referendum in Oregon, and subsequently, when the Initiative and Referendum had been victorious, had failed to report the victory. "Just think of it!" said this amiable old gentleman. "My radical friend actually believed that the Associated Press would have some motive in suppressing news about the success of the Initiative and Referendum in Oregon!"
I was called upon to answer this argument. I quote from an account of the discussion in the "New York Call":
Sinclair was saying that when the fusion of capitalism beat Seidel
(Socialist) in Milwaukee, the wires were full of it, but when Duncan
(Socialist) beat a fusion in Butte, the press was as silent as the
tomb. Franklin said that it was merely that Butte had no news
value, while Milwaukee, "Schlitz beer—everybody wants to know about
Milwaukee."
Incidentally I might mention in passing that this amiable
old gentleman, Mr. Fabian Franklin, who thinks that the
Associated Press would be incapable of suppressing news
about a triumph of the Initiative and Referendum, and that it
would naturally send out political news about Milwaukee because
Schlitz beer is made in Milwaukee, has just recently been
selected by a group of reactionaries to conduct a weekly organ
of safety and sanity, "The Review." The reader will be
able from the above anecdote to form an idea of the intellectual
status of Mr. Franklin, and the likelihood of his having anything
worth while to say to the American people in this
greatest crisis of history!
Shortly afterwards came the case of the "Masses," which published a cartoon representing the president of the Associated Press as pouring a bottle labeled "Poison" into a reservoir entitled "Public Opinion." The Associated Press caused the arrest of Max Eastman and Art Young on a charge of criminal libel. They knew that by starting such a proceeding they would gain an opportunity of propaganda, and of this they hastened to make use. They issued an elaborate
