Then the indictment quotes another paragraph from the editorial:
The representative of the Associated Press was an officer in that
military tribunal that hounded the Paint Creek miners into the penitentiary
in violation of their constitutional liberties; and this fact is
even more significant and more serious than the abrogation of those
liberties. It shows that the one thing which all tribes and nations
in time have held sacred—the body of Truth—is for sale to organized
capital in the United States.
The indictment interprets this as follows:
Meaning and intending thereby that the said corporation was
willing to and did in consideration of money paid to it knowingly
supply to its members information of such untruthful, biased and
prejudiced nature and so distorted and incomplete as the person paying such money might desire.
This indictment was widely heralded in the press, and
everybody thought they were going to get the truth about the
Associated Press at last. But when the case was ready for
trial, it was mysteriously dropped. For six years I have wondered
why it was dropped. I cannot say now that I know;
but I have just met Max Eastman, and heard from his lips
the story of a certain eminent corporation lawyer in New
York, who on several occasions has "kicked over the traces"
of Big Business. This man knows a great deal about the
Associated Press, and he came forward in this "Masses" case,
offering to assist the defense, and to conduct the trial. It was
his plan to summon the heads of high finance in New York,
beginning with Pierpont Morgan, and to question them as to
the precise details of their relationship to the Associated Press!
Aren't you sorry that trial didn't come off? And don't you
think it a very serious matter that the Associated Press did
not face this precise and definite issue, which it had so publicly
raised? Let me speak for myself: If any man accused me in
the specific and damaging way above quoted, I would consider
that my time, my money, my energy, my very life must be
called to the task of vindicating my honor. And if, instead of
fighting, I put my tail between my legs and sneaked away from
the scene, I would expect men to conclude that there was some
guilt upon my conscience.
