A. No, sir. I had a great many communications with individual producers; I think with more than half the producers, estimating them by the quality of oil produced.
Q. State what occurred.
A. I have corresponded with them and in that correspondence they have expressed their belief that the proposed plan of the South Improvement Company would work greatly for the benefit of the producing interest; that there was something greatly needed for the producing interest, and that it could not thrive without something of this kind, because it could not pay fair, living rates, for transportation to the railroad companies at the price oil was bringing, and that there was no likelihood of oil increasing in price under the existing condition of things; that the railroad could not always, of course, continue carrying at a loss.
·······
Q. Will you give the names of the producers who proposed to join the South Improvement Company, or who expressed themselves favourable to the plan of that company, in addition to the name of Mr. Mitchell?
A. I could give you the names of several of them, but I do not think their lives and property would be safe. They requested me not to mention their names because they thought it would be an imprudent thing to do.
Q. You refuse, then, to give the names which you say you could state?
A. I refuse to give the names for the reason I have stated.
Q. Are there any of them you are willing to mention?
A. I will look over the letters and see whether there are any of them not marked confidential. If there are any not so marked, I will give you the names.
Q. Why do you state to this committee that you are not willing to give the names of the parties to whom you refer, when you state that a great many producers were in favour of this plan, and were consulted in regard to it?
A. I stated it because it was a fact.
By Mr. Sheldon.
Q. Did the danger to the lives of these parties arise from the excitement in the Oil Regions in consequence of these proceedings?
A. Yes, sir, one of the presidents of one of the committees representing the producers was in New York, a Mr. Patterson. He stated, as I understood, to one of the railroad officers, that he did not think my life would be safe if I were to go into the Oil Region, although he himself would not take it. I had received a number of threatening letters, but I did not attach any importance to them until Mr. Patterson made that statement.
By the Chairman.
Q. What was the reason given why your life would not be safe?
A. I do not know that the reason given, I think by Mr. Patterson, that there was such an unreasonable excitement among the people as to the nature and object of the
[ 313 ]
