A. I think about that time they did.
Q. Was it for a short time raised to that amount, and a printed schedule published ?
A. I never saw the published schedule; I understood that through a mistake between William Vanderbilt, vice-president of the New York Central Railroad Company and freight agent of the Lake Shore road, it was supposed by the freight agent of the Lake Shore road that the rate had been raised by an agreement among the railroads to the maximum rates mentioned in their contracts with the South Improvement Company. A day or two after that mistake, being in Mr. Vanderbilt's office, a telegram came in respect to it, and Mr. Vanderbilt at once directed the correction to be made. Mr. Devereux, the general manager of the Lake Shore Railroad, happened to come in at the time, and he also gave directions to the officers of his road to have the correction promptly made.
Q. Were you present?
A. Yes, sir, I was present. When I said "being in Mr. Vanderbilt's office," I meant that I myself was present.
Q. Was the correction made at your instance, or request, or suggestion?
A. It was not.
By Mr. Hambleton.
Q. Why was it made?
A. Because it was a mistake, a misapprehension, a misunderstanding, as I understood. I had not heard anything of it before that moment, and it was accidental, as I said, that I heard it.
By the Chairman.
Q. Then the rates were raised by the freight agents of the roads to correspond with the rates mentioned in these contracts?
A. I do not know the facts any further than having heard it as I have stated.
Q. And you think they were raised to correspond with these contracts by mistake?
A. I stated I so understood at the time.
Q. You stated the circumstances so minutely as to its being a mistake between Mr. Vanderbilt and the Lake Shore agent, that I inferred you knew the facts?
A. I only know it was so represented at the time.
Q. Did you take any part in that conversation by which the error you speak of was corrected?
A. Only in this sense: Mr. Vanderbilt mentioned the fact to me that a mistake of that kind had been made, that he had just received a despatch in relation to it, and he was about to correct it, and he asked me, I think, if I knew whether Mr. Devereux had given any orders respecting the matter. I told him I did not know anything about it.
[ 319 ]
