has been much alarm at the intimation of such a projected usurpation, and much consultation, and a spirit
fully manifested not to submit to it," wrote Monroe
to Jefferson on January 18, 1801, two days before
Marshall's nomination as Chief Justice. These rumors,
whether true or false, and the known fact that Marshall,
while taking no active part, was not entirely averse to
the election of Burr to the Presidency, very naturally
increased the new President's personal prejudice against
the new Chief Justice.[1] It is entirely probable also
that Jefferson was aware of Marshall's personal views.
"To Mr. Jefferson . . . I have felt almost insuperable
objections," Marshall wrote to Hamilton. "His foreign prejudices seem to me totally to unfit him for the
chief magistracy. In addition to this solid and
immovable objection, Mr. Jefferson appears to me to
be a man who will embody himself with the House of
Representatives. By weakening the office of President, he will increase his personal power. He will
- ↑ See Marshall, II, 542. As to Marshall's views relative to the election and Burr,
see articles Washington Federalist, Jan. 6, 21, 25, Feb. 6, 12, 1801, which it was
generally supposed (and with some reason, as Beveridge believes) were either writ-
ten or inspired by Marshall.
The coolness existing between the Chief Justice and the President, after the latter's election, may be inferred from the following amusing reference. The Washington Federalist, quoted in Columbian Centinel, Aug. 29, 1801, stated: "There was such a gang of strange beings continually haunting the President's house, crying More, More! Give, Give! that the President thought proper to decamp. The presence of the Chief Justice perhaps had some effect in hastening his depar- ture." The National Aegis, Dec. 12, 1801, charged Marshall with being "the malignant enemy of the President." The Aurora's Washington correspondent, March 8, 1805, describing Jefferson's second inauguration, wrote: "The President and Vice-President were sworn in today. The concourse of spectators was immense. Four of the Judges of the Supreme Court, Chief Justice Marshall, Cushing, Paterson and Washington; and I observed that the Judge did not turn his back upon the President whilst administering the oath as he did this day four years ago."
one of the representatives (I think Randolph) and has excited the utmost indignation in the Legislature."
The Connecticut Courant, March 28, 1801, contained an account of an interview
with James Hillhouse, late President pro-tem of the Senate, stating that these
rumors as to projected action of Congress were utterly false and that he never
heard of the plan reported by the Aurora, until the Aurora published it.