25
may lead to sub-dialect, and how each dialect may thus be bound together with the life of another by a “continuous series of minute variations.” But we are confronted in the science of Greek dialectology with phenomena dating from historical periods; for these phenomena we must seek a historical explanation as far as is permitted by the dim light of history. The wave-theory regards as merely interesting confirmations of its suppositions those causes of differentiation of a linguistic territory which to its opponents are the very sinew of the genealogical theory, It may well be questioned whether Schmnidt’s theory does not confuse these processes which caused dialects originally to come into existence, and those processes which give birth to phenomena that have become in historical times the property of two adjacent dialects which have flourished for a long period of time. Peculiarities which link together two dialects may be ascribed to the influence of one upon the other; but in periods antedating all historical ken the influence of a neighboring speech-territory need not necessarily have been the cause of dialectic peculiarities.
If linguistic phenomena alone be taken as the point of departure, we must confess that we thereby seek a refuge in a sauve qui peut, and renounce that ideal whose every patient endeavor aims at discovering in the disiecta membra of dialect-speech a clue that will reinforce those utterances of antiquity which make for the intimate connection between parent-stock and the offspring which, in periods subject to conjecture alone, left an ancestral home. This ideal in dialectology is as important a guiding motive as the ideal of the freedom from exception to phonetic law is in the science of comparative philology. We have, then, at least no mean purpose, if we search for the golden thread that shall lead us to an explanation of the genealogy of each separate form. With this ideal in view we may perhaps discover that, when the forms of adventitious growth have been separated from those which are indigenous, it is not impossible to construct genealogical trees for the Greek dialects, which will stand in harmonious interdependence. If we endeavor to sift the material which a kind chance has preserved to us, and believe that terra mater noua miracula suis ex uisceribus numquam emittere cessabit, we may trust that a solution may not be far off for many problems which the vigorous dialect-life of Hellas presents.
Herbert Weir Smyth.
