manure, was expressly forbidden as a health menace. In August 1868 the directors planned the spur to the new dock and in March 1869 a bill was introduced into the Legislature to permit such construction. Over the summer the single track spur was laid from the main line at about the present junction of Metropolitan & Flushing Avenues north to the dock just above where Maspeth Avenue used to intersect Newtown Creek before it was obliterated by the Navy Yard. Whether there were cranes here for loading and unloading manure barges is uncertain; however, the railroad went ahead in February 1872 with another freight dock at Hunter's Point installing $25,000 worth of facilities.
From the day the South Side RR opened in October 1867, it seems to have been well patronized and successful. Part of the reason for this prosperity was undoubtedly its newness: new engines, new cars, and a new and heavy roadbed. The South Side also had the advantage over its rival, the Long Island RR, of passing directly through old and well-established villages all along the south shore. A third attraction was its fare schedule, which generally set rates slightly below those of the Long Island RR. Between 1868 and 1872 the following fares prevailed from New York or Brooklyn:
| Fresh Pond or Glendale | 15¢ | South Oyster Bay (Massapequa) | 85¢ | |
| Richmond Hill or Jamaica | 18¢ | Amityville | 95¢ | |
| Springfield | 40¢ | Breslau (Lindenhurst) & | ||
| Valley Stream | 45¢ | Babylon | 1.10 | |
| Lynbrook | 50¢ | Bayshore | 1.20 | |
| Rockville Centre | 55¢ | Islip | 1.35 | |
| Baldwin | 60¢ | Oakdale | 1.45 | |
| Freeport | 65¢ | Sayville | 1.55 | |
| Merrick | 70¢ | Bayport | 1.60 | |
| Wantagh (Ridgewood) | 75¢ | Patchogue | 1.65 |
A glance at this table reveals that where the South Side was in competition with the Long Island RR between New York and Jamaica, the fares were very low (18¢) but east of Jamaica the rates rose sharply and then leveled off. In February 1869 the South Side offered the residents of Jamaica single tickets for only 15¢ or a book of 100 for $12. When Charlick found his rival getting all the traffic, he cut his rates to the same figure, then fearful of a war, arranged a meeting with Fox, resulting in
