The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda/Volume 9/Excerpts from Sister Nivedita's Book/IX Walks And Talks Beside The Jhelum
PERSONS: The Swami Vivekananda and a party of Europeans and disciples,
amongst whom were Dhira Mata, the "Steady Mother"; one whose name was Jaya;
TIME: July 20 to July 29, 1898.
. . . . . .
That morning the river was broad and shallow and clear, and two of us walked with the Swami across the fields and along the banks about three miles. He began by talking of the sense of sin, how it was Egyptian, Semitic and Aryan. It appears in the Vedas, but quickly passes out. The devil is recognized there as the Lord of Anger. Then, with the Buddhists he became Mara, the Lord of Lust, and one of the most loved of the Lord Buddha's titles was "Conqueror of Mara". (Vide the Sanskrit lexicon Amarkosha that Swami learnt to patter as a child of four!) But while Satan is the Hamlet of the Bible, in the Hindu scriptures the Lord of Anger never divides creation. He always represents defilement, never duality.
Zoroaster was a reformer of some old religion. Even Ormuzd and Ahriman with
him were not supreme; they were only manifestations of the Supreme. That
older religion must have been Vedantic. So the Egyptians and Semites cling
to the theory of sin while the Aryans, as Indians and Greeks, quickly lose
it. In India righteousness and sin become Vidyâ and Avidyâ — both to be
transcended. Amongst the Aryans, Persians and Europeans become Semitized by
religious ideas; hence the sense of sin.*
And then the talk drifted, as it was always so apt to do, to questions of
the country and the future. What idea must be urged on a people to give them
strength? The line of their own development runs in one way, A. Must the new
accession of force be a compensating one, B? This would produce a
development midway between the two, C — a geometrical alteration merely. But
it was not so.
National life was a question of organic forces. We must reinforce the current of that life itself, and leave it to do the rest. Buddha preached renunciation, and India heard. Yet within a thousand years she had reached her highest point of national prosperity. The national life in India has renunciation as its source. Its highest ideals are service and Mukti. The Hindu mother eats last. Marriage is not for individual happiness, but for the welfare of the nation and the caste. Certain individuals of the modern reform, having embarked on an experiment which could not solve the problem, "are the sacrifices over which the race has to walk".
And then the trend of conversation changed again and became all fun and
merriment, jokes and stories. And as we laughed and listened, the boats came
up and talk was over for the day.
The whole of that afternoon and night the Swami lay in his boat, ill. But
next day, when we landed at the temple of Bijbehara — already thronged with
Amarnath pilgrims — he was able to join us for a little while. "Quickly up
and quickly down", as he said of himself, was always his characteristic.
After that he was with us most of the day, and in the afternoon we reached
Islamabad. . . .
In the dusk that evening one came into the little group amongst the apple
trees and found the Master engaged in the rarest of rare happenings, a
personal talk with Dhira Mata and her whose name was Jaya. He had taken two
pebbles into his hand and was saying how, when he was well, his mind might
direct itself to this and that, or his will might seem less firm; but let
the least touch of pain or illness come, let him look death in the face for
a while, and "I am as hard as that (knocking the stones together), for I
have touched the feet of God".
And one remembered, apropos of this coolness, the story of a walk across the
fields in England, where he and an Englishman and woman had been pursued by
an angry bull. The Englishman frankly ran and reached the other side of the
hill in safety. The woman ran as far as she could and then sank to the
ground, incapable of further effort. Seeing this, and unable to aid her, the
Swami — thinking "So this is the end, after all" — took up his stand in
front of her, with folded arms. He told afterwards how his mind was occupied
with a mathematical calculation as to how far the bull would be able to
throw. But the animal suddenly stopped a few paces off and then, raising his
head, retreated sullenly.
A like courage — though he himself was far from thinking of these incidents
— had shown itself in his early youth when he quietly stepped up to a
runaway horse and caught it in the streets of Calcutta, thus saving the life
of the woman who occupied the carriage behind.
The talk drifted on, as we sat on the grass beneath the trees, and became,
for an hour or two, half grave, half gay. We heard much of the tricks the
monkeys could play in Vrindaban. And we elicited stories of two separate
occasions in his wandering life when he had had clear previsions of help
which had been fulfilled. One of these I remember. It may possibly have
occurred at the time when he was under the vow to ask for nothing, and he
had been several days (perhaps five) without food. Suddenly, as he lay
almost dying of exhaustion in a railway-station, it flashed into his mind
that he must rise up and go out along a certain road and that there he would
meet a man bringing him help. He obeyed and met one carrying a tray of food.
"Are you he to whom I was sent?" said this man, coming up to him and looking
at him closely.
Then a child was brought to us, with its hand badly cut, and the Swami applied an old wives' cure. He bathed the wound with water and then laid on it, to stop the bleeding, the ashes of a piece of calico. The villagers were soothed and consoled, and our gossip was over for the evening.
The next morning a motley gathering of coolies assembled beneath the
apple-trees and waited some hours to take us to the ruins of Marttanda. It
had been a wonderful old building — evidently more abbey than temple — in a
wonderful position; and its great interest lay in the obvious agglomeration
of styles and periods in which it had grown up. . . . Its presence is a
perpetual reminder that the East was the original home of monasticism. The
Swami was hard at work in an instant on observations and theories, pointing
out the cornice that ran along the nave from the entrance to the sanctuary,
to the west, surmounted by the high trefoils of the two arches and also by a
frieze; or showing us the panels containing cherubs; and before we had done,
had picked up a couple of coins. The ride back through the sunset light was
charming. From all these hours, the day before and the day after, fragments
of talk come back to me.
"No nation, not Greek or another, has ever carried patriotism so far as the Japanese. They don't talk, they act — give up all for country. There are noblemen now living in Japan as peasants, having given up their princedoms without a word to create the unity of the empire.* And not one traitor could be found in the Japanese war. Think of that!"
Again, talking of the inability of some to express feeling, "Shy and reserved people, I have noticed, are always the most brutal when roused".
Again, evidently talking of the ascetic life and giving the rules of
Brahmacharya — "The Sannyâsin who thinks of gold, to desire it, commits
suicide", and so on.
The darkness of night and the forest, a great pine-fire under the trees, two
or three tents standing out white in the blackness, the forms and voices of
many servants at their fires in the distance, and the Master with three
disciples, such is the next picture. . . . Suddenly the Master turned to one
member of the party and said, "You never mention your school now. Do you
sometimes forget it? You see", he went on, "I have much to think of. One day
I turn to Madras and think of the work there. Another day I give all my
attention to America or England or Ceylon or Calcutta. Now I am thinking
At that moment the Master was called away to dine, and not till he came back
could the confidence he had invited be given.
He listened to it all, the deliberate wish for a tentative plan, for smallness of beginnings, and the final inclination to turn away from the idea of inclusiveness and breadth and to base the whole of an educational effort on the religious life and on the worship of Shri Ramakrishna.
"Because you must be sectarian to get that enthusiasm, must you not?" he
said. "You will make a sect in order to rise above all sects. Yes I
There would be obvious difficulties. The thing sounded on this scale almost
impossible for many reasons. But for the moment the only care need be to
will rightly; and if the plan was sound, ways and means would be found to
hand, that was sure.
He waited a little when he had heard it all, and then he said, "You ask me
to criticize, but that I cannot do. For I regard you as inspired, quite as
much inspired as I am. You know that's the difference between other
religions and us. Other people believe their founder was inspired, and so do
we. But so am I also, just as much so as he, and you as I; and after you,
your girls and their disciples will be. So I shall help you to do what you
Then he turned to Dhira Mata and to Jaya and spoke of the greatness of the
trust that he would leave in the hands of that disciple who should represent
the interests of women when he should go West, of how it would exceed the
responsibility of work for men. And he added, turning to the worker of the
party, "Yes, you have faith, but you have not that burning enthusiasm that
you need. You want to be consumed [with] energy. Shiva! Shiva!" And so,
invoking the blessing of Mahâdeva, he said goodnight and left us, and we
presently went to bed.
The next morning we breakfasted early in one of the tents and went on to
Achhabal. One of us had had a dream of old jewels lost and restored, all
bright and new. But the Swami, smiling, stopped the tale, saying, "Never
talk of a dream as good as that!"
At Achhabal we found more gardens of Jehangir. Was it here or at Verinag
that had been his favourite resting-place?
We roamed about the gardens and bathed in a still pool opposite the Pathan
Khan's Zenana, and then we lunched in the first garden and rode down in the
afternoon to Islamabad.
As we sat at lunch, the Swami invited his daughter to go to the cave of
Amarnath with him and be dedicated to Shiva. Dhira Mata smiled permission,
and the next half-hour was given to pleasure and congratulations. It had
already been arranged that we were all to go to Pahalgam and wait there for
the Swami's return from the pilgrimage. So we reached the boats that
evening, packed and wrote letters, and next day in the afternoon started for