This speech also appears in the Proceedings of the Chamber of Commerce for November 18, 1890 in the Thirty-Third Annual Report of the Corporation of the Chamber of Commerce of the State of New York for the year 1890-'91, pp. 48-55. This supplements the poor documentation of this clipping taken from the Papers of Carl Schurz in the Library of Congress. Sometimes the pages in the PDF overlap considerably, and only the text not in the previous page is transcribed.