Translation:Shulchan Aruch/Yoreh Deah/96

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
The Laws of a Sharp Food That Was Cut with a Meat Knife
translated from Hebrew by Mordechai Leib Rothenberg and Wikisource
3713893The Laws of a Sharp Food That Was Cut with a Meat KnifeMordechai Leib Rothenberg

1) Radish or beets that were cut with a meat knife, used that day or that was not cleaned off are not allowed to be eaten with dairy, until a slice is removed from the location of the cutting that is an "amount to be taken." This amount is equivalent to the width of a thumb. Or let it be tasted, and if it does not have the taste of meat it can be eaten with dairy with mere rinsing. There are those who say that this is also the rule with a knife that was not used that day and was cleaned off. And if you did not take the "amount to be taken" and you did not taste it and you cooked it with Milk, you need 60 times the amount that the knife touched, and this is the rule for something that was cut with a knife of a Non-Jew. Rema: If one cuts [a radish] very finely [i.e., dicing], one needs 60 times against the entire radish.And some say the same is true if it is cut with a meat knife the entire radish is prohibited with dairy. And this is our practice ab initio, however after the fact only an "amount to be taken" is rendered forbidden. And this is only true if the radish itself was cut, but if the radish greens were cut there is no cause for concern. And if there is doubt if the radish was cut with a non-kosher knife, we are lenient. And so too we purchase radishes that were cut on their tops for we can assume they were cut with garden tools.And in a place where only knife-cut radishes can be found, the practice is to permit them through removing an "amount to be taken."

(2) If one cut garlic, onions, kerishin, and tamcha (known as krayn) and other things that are similarly sharp, or pickled fruits, or salted fish, they all have the same laws as one who cuts a radish. Rema: And it is nonetheless permissible to eat spice mixtures made by gentiles like ginger since they use special tools to prepare it our pull it out of the ground without cutting.

(3)Spices that are ground in a meat mortar that had been used within 24 hours should not be eaten together with dairy. Rema: And some say even if it was not used within 24 hours.

(4) Lemon juice made by gentiles and cut pieces of salted fish that are brought by gentiles in barrels are permitted. Rema: Because they bring large quantities at once and even if some of them are prohibited, for they were cut first with a non-kosher knife, they are nullified amidst the others that are subsequently cut, for the ones cut later do not become prohibited for the taste in the knife was nullified in the first items cut and so the entire group is permitted. And so too all cases of this sort. Therefore in some places they eat cabbage called kompast, even though it is cut open and chopped. And there are some places where they are strick about that and one should not change the practice. But other things that are not sharp, like apples or dry turnips, the practice is to permit just like lemons and one should not be strict at all.

(5) If one cuts squash with a meat knife can eat it with dairy if he merely scrapes away the place of cutting. And if he cuts a turnip, even that scraping is not required, rather mere rinsing suffices. Not only that, but even a radish cut after a turnip can be eaten with dairy after mere rinsing just like the turnip itself because the taste of the turnip changes and nullifies the taste absorbed from the knife. Rema: This is only true about turnips for its taste is changes, but vegetables or bread or other things do not accomplish this. And even after cutting a turnip one should not cut a radish more than once, unless he cuts turnip between each cut of the radish.