First general rule: A translation should give a complete transcript of the ideas of the original work.—Knowledge of the language of the original, and acquaintance with the subject.—Examples of imperfect transfusion of the sense of the original—What ought to be the conduct of a translator where the sense is ambiguous,
Of the freedom allowed in poetical Translation.—Progress of poetical Translation in England.—B. Jonson, Holiday, Sandys, Fanshaw, Dryden.—Roscommon's Essay on translated Verse.—Pope's Homer,
Second general Rule: The style and manner of writing in a Translation should be of the same character with that of the Original.—A just Taste requisite for the discernment of the Characters of Style and Manner.—Examples of failure in this particular:—The grave exchanged for the formal;—the elevated for the bombast;—the lively for the petulant;—the simple for the childish.—Hobbes, L'Estrange, Eachard, &c.
Examples of a good Taste in poetical Translation.—Bourne's Translations from Mallet and from Prior.—The Duke de Nivernois from Horace. Mr Webb from the Anthologia.—Fragments of the Greek Dramatis by Mr Cumberland.
Limitation of the Rule regarding the Imitation of Style.—This Imitation must be regulated by the Genius of Languages.—The Latin admits of a greater brevity of Expression than the English; as does the French.—The Latin and Greek allow of greater Inversions than the English,—and admit more freely of Ellipsis,
Third General Rule: A translation should have all the ease of original composition.—Extreme difficulty in the observance of this rule.—Contrasted instances of success and failure, difficulty in the observance of this rule.— Contrasted instances of success and failure,
It is less difficult to attain the ease of original composition in Poetical, than in Prose Translation.—Lyric Poetry admits of the greatest liberty of Translation.—Examples distinguishing Paraphrase from Translation,—from Dryden, Lowth, Hughes,
Of the Translation of idiomatic phrases.—Examples from Cotton, Eachard, Sterne.—Injudicious use of idioms in the translation, which do not correspond with the age or country of the original.—Idiomatic phrases sometimes incapable of translation,
Difficulty of translating Don Quixote, from its idiomatic phraseology.—Of the best translations of that novel.—Comparison of the translation by Motteux with that by Smollet,
The genius of the translator should be akin to that of the original author.—The best translators have shone in original composition of the same species with that which they have translated.—Of Voltaire's translations from Shakespeare.—Of the peculiar character of the wit of Voltaire.—His translation from Hudibras.—Excellent anonymous French translation of Hudibras.—Translation of Rabelais by Urquhart and Motteux,